I'm very pleased with this rug, it fits nicely, is light but warm, the quality is good and the buckle front means there's some adjustment within the size. The price is also good, it seems to be getting harder to find a nice detachable neck rug without spending a lot of money.
My only problem with this rug, and I've discussed it with Vanessa who got back to me quickly, is that I found the neck cover wasn't deep enough for my cob. It was easily fixed by a saddler, but it was a bit irritating. However in fairness to Swish I've now had just the same problem with another make and a hood by a brand known to be roomy is snug on him - clearly while he doesn't look heavy through the neck he isn't a standard fit even for a cob! Maybe it's a combination of size and a high carriage?
Overall I love the rug - though maybe a more muted colour would be a nice option! - and would certainly recommend to friends or buy this make again if I want another rug.